Why chess can be so painful (and the antidote)
September 25th, 2024
33 mins 39 secs
Tags
About this Episode
Sign up for a free Real Chess Training Test, for players between 1500-2000: https://nextlevelchess.kit.com/rct-trial
Get my free eBook, 'The Art of Chess Improvement': https://nextlevelchess.com/free-ebook/
Additional Free Content:
➡️Weekly Newsletter: https://nextlevelchess.com/newsletter/
➡️Blog with 200+ articles: https://nextlevelchess.com/articles/
➡️YouTube Channel: https://www.youtube.com/@GMnoelstuder
Check out my courses:
➡️My holistic chess improvement system: https://nextlevelchess.com/simplified-chess-improvement-system/
➡️Reach 1200+ Elo with my Beginner Fundamental course: https://nextlevelchess.com/beginner-chess-mastery/
➡️Real Chess Training: The weekly 6 position Test Membership for players between 1500-2000 chesscom Rapid: https://nextlevelchess.com/real-chess-training/
Transcript
Why losing at chess hurts so much with intro ===
Speaker: [00:00:00] Welcome back to next level chess podcast. I am grandmaster Noël Studer and on this podcast I want to help you improve your chess. I'll talk about anything that might impact your chess improvement from mindset to playing against lower or higher rated opponents to the effective and efficient training to make sure that you're not wasting your valuable time when you train chess.
Before we get into today's episode, I just want to remind you that you can get much more chess improvement advice if you visit my homepage, which is nextlevelchess. blog and over there you can find 150 plus articles. You can subscribe to my free newsletter, you can check out my courses, And all of that will be also linked in the description of this podcast episode.
Read Full Transcript Hide Full Transcript
So if you want to learn more from me, make sure to check all of that stuff [00:01:00] out. Now let's get into today's topic. Oh boy, chess can be a mental struggle, especially when we have bad period in chess. Somehow it seems to affect most people mentally, emotionally, you know, it's just extremely, extremely tough.
And recently I've got a few readers and listeners asking me similar questions. Why chess hurts so much and why we take it so personally when we lose Chess and in my own experience. I also had tournaments that I had to recover from like for weeks Like I would feel bad about myself Feel that I am stupid.
I am bad. I will never get good at chess and this same thing doesn't really happen in other board games or other sports, I feel like and So today I want to dig into why chess can be so [00:02:00] tough You And how you can adjust and make chess a little bit less hard on your mind and feel less bad about yourself.
And this goes both for professional players and amateur players. So I will start this podcast episode now by reading out a message I got from a reader a while back and then also a few, you know, other ideas or things that people gave me to talk about. And then I will give you my idea of how I managed to make chess less painful and more a joy and more process focused.
Okay, so this is Ted Manaza. writing me and I'm going to quote him. Hey Noel, I just read your excellent article on avoiding time trouble. It got me thinking, why does the game of chess produce such a strong [00:03:00] fear in players? I can think of no other game that elicits as strong of an upset when one loses than chess.
When I lose at Settlers of Catan, By the way, this is Noel speaking again. I love that game, Settlers of Catan, and me and my friends can get a little bit upset as well. But let's talk about the topic. So I go back into quote, or clue, or even tic tac toe, it's fine. But losing a game of chess puts me in a bad mood all day.
I have a feeling that most chess players would relate to this. My question is, why is chess such a disproportionately big deal to us? Is it because chess is famously associated with an individual's intelligence and therefore we interpret a loss as a critique on our intelligence? It certainly feels somewhat like that to me, because when I review my mistakes after a game, my internal commentary goes something like, [00:04:00] I can't believe I was so dumb, I don't even play competitively, yet that is how I feel.
Could it also be because chess outcomes are immediately and explicitly rated? On the opposite end, if I have a good game, I feel very smart. As if chess validated my internal perception of my intelligence. Read Ego. Even when I was competitive in Taekwondo and Jiu Jitsu, a loss never felt as sharp as a chess loss, even though I could get seriously hurt in those sports.
So this is end of quotation. That was a long question, but basically saying you. Why does chess and losing a chess hurt so much more and why do we take it so much more personal than other games and other sports? And by the way, this is something I didn't realize when I was active, that this is the same for most people.
professional [00:05:00] players and amateurs. And that's why I want to talk about it. So thank you so much for the message, Ted. And now I want to switch to an other message, which I got when releasing my podcast which was Gabriel saying that he is scared to click play. And he has a crazy anxiety about starting a game because losing in chess hurts.
So much. So definitely there are even more readers that, you know, wrote me over the years. Why does it hurt so much? So this is a very important point and I want to dissect this in three steps. So first I want to. Consider why is chess such a disproportionately big deal to us. Then I want to talk about what the difference is with other games or sports.
So why isn't it the same in other areas? And then last and most importantly, I want to give you tools and mental tricks [00:06:00] that help me limit the downside. So help me, you know, be a little bit less emotional, hate myself less when I play, when I lose games, when I play badly, take everything less personal.
Okay. Let's get into why losing a game of chess is such a big deal. There are a few key factors that differ chess from other games or sports. And I do believe that these differences are offering some answers as to why or wellbeing depends much more on the chess results than a settlers of Catan results or a tic tac toe results.
The immediate factors I see are the immediate feedback. So that's number one. We in chess, we have an incredible immediate feedback. Then number two is social. stereotypes. So that was what Ted mess mentioned as well, which is if you're good at chess, you're smart. And then the third thing that comes to [00:07:00] mind is that in chess, there is no luck involved, no chance involved.
So we can't offload a loss to something out of our control. Actually we can, some people do that, but it, or subconscious will feel that this is basically BSing ourself. So let's get into the immediate feedback loop. So chess is very interesting because we have actually two immediate feedbacks that happen after every game we play.
And as we have everything online right now, we can play so many games. So really have an eternal loop of immediate feedback, which can be very interesting. Hard to take. So there is feedback number one, which is a rating feedback. So every game you play is rated or most games you play on online are rated.
So you lose rating. If you lose the game, you win rating. If you win a game, if you compare that to [00:08:00] some other sport, that's nearly nowhere the case. And because of social stereotypes, more to that later on, we strongly cling to our rating. So we really feel attached to our rating. I see that, for example, with people having in their Twitter bio I'm a 1735 rated chess player.
So that means that the rating is part of their identity. So when you lose a game, Your identity drops because your rating is part of your identity, your identity drops and that can make it more painful. Also every time you sit again at the board or you play again online, you will get reminded of your past bad results.
So let's say you have 1750 and you lose a few games, you drop down to 1720. You can now leave the computer, go somewhere else. But whenever you [00:09:00] come back, And you see, Oh shit, I really have that bad rating. You will be reminded of your bad results. So every time it's like having on your head, like a classification, a rating, and that can make it very, very tough.
So this is different than, for example, if you lose a board game or a tennis match, usually. You're not, you know, having that immediate, Oh, you just dropped like in Switzerland, in tennis, we have like numbers, but they don't change after every game. And especially if you play just with friends. There is no, you know change on the results whereas in chess as most of us now play online There is always a change of your Of your rating now, there's a second thing That is very very tough and it might be even worse than the rating feedback, which is the engine feedback so in [00:10:00] chess We can look at every single move we played if you play online, you can look at hundreds of thousands of moves you played and the engine will tell you this was bad.
This was really bad. This was horrible. That move really sucked. And why do you even play this move? Right? So you have like a voice in your head or a tech, you know, screaming at you and just giving you a question mark, double question mark, you know, just. bad, bad, bad. Everything is bad because chess is so hard.
It is normal that most of your games will contain big mistakes and the engine will point that out immediately. You can switch it on in one second. Boom, right? You, you make the game analysis and it drops and up and down and question marks and everything. Now, if you compare that, so playing a game and then switching on the engine, if you compare that with other sports, like imagine playing tennis.
With an engine you're playing tennis, right? So you hit the ball and now somebody [00:11:00] would scream at you or let's say you finish a set or something And now you go watch re watch the video and your coach says you this hit was horrible That hit was bad. That hit was bad. That hit was bad, and it's not based on what you should know.
So maybe you're a beginning player, so the coach doesn't take that into consideration, but he's just taking, okay, you need to play as Roger Federer. Like Roger Federer would have played this better, would have played this better, would have played this better. Like you would quit immediately, probably. Like this is just insanely difficult to do that.
But we in chess have exactly that. Not only that, we are not compared to Magnus. Carlson, but we're even compared to a stronger version like the engines are way stronger than the best humans So what you're analyzing your games and your decisions with and what is giving you feedback is most Often something the machine that is way stronger than any human will ever B.
So this [00:12:00] requires a lot of attention and a lot of thinking about how to take that feedback from the engine. And we will get to that when we go to the solutions, but that's very important. So we have two immediate feedback loops, which is rating is always changing and the engine screaming at you after everything that you do wrong.
Now let's go to the society stereotypes. Now, why does it even matter if we are good at chess or not? Isn't it just a hobby we should enjoy practicing? In theory, yes. I absolutely second the idea that if you enjoy a hobby, you don't really need to worry about your results. If you enjoy the moment, That's the point of a hobby, but it's not that easy because our society is very results driven.
And then also improvement is kind of fun. So if you always stagnate, you probably won't have that much fun anymore. So as a chess player, we are [00:13:00] usually seen as very smart. I can't tell you how many times I was somewhere else, not in a chess context. And at some point, somebody would ask me, what are you doing?
In your life and I would say I'm a chess grandmaster or I'm a chess coach or something like this and the most you know likely answer of somebody is Oh my god, you must be a genius like it's always happening Either they think you're absolute freak complete idiot wasting your time on 64 squares Or they think that you're just too good The most amazing genius they have ever met like there's basically no in between and because of that stereotype this does does not only hit grandmasters But even if somebody says hey i'm a you know national master in chess people think that you are, you know super intelligent and that will maybe even give you, you know, a ego boost, but also chop opportunities.[00:14:00]
I have a good friend in Switzerland that was at a job interview for a position in finance. And basically the job interview wasn't going very well. And at some point the interview, the interviewer would say a chess analogy and my friend would say, Oh, actually I'm playing chess. I liked that analogy.
And he would look at him with huge eyes and the feeling of the interview was going from I probably never give you a job to like just tell me how much money you want You were a 2000 rated chess player take my money. I'll employ you. You're amazing because this you know, interviewer was maybe a 1200 rated chess player.
So in his mind, it was like, okay, this guy must be a genius, right? So there is this social kind of hierarchy of bad chess player, dumb good chess player, smart that we, every single game [00:15:00] we use it for ourselves. So. I play a good game of chess. I'm smart. I play a bad game of chess. I'm stupid. And that's really hard on our mind.
And again, it's very important to understand that to understand what could be the solution to be less, be less stupid. You know, pained when we play and that has to do with identifying with chess results or in other words, not identifying that much anymore with chess results. So as Ted observes, a loss can make him feel stupid as a person.
A win can make him feel smart. So, as I mentioned already, for the people that have like a, I'm a 1735 rated chess player. It's very hard for them to actually then drop below 1700 because nearly part of their identity is based on that. Breaking away. And usually when [00:16:00] my fiance Alessia would ask me shortly after a tournament, how I feel, I would just take the last result as a baseline of my feeling like, Hey baby, how do you feel?
Yeah, it's decent. Taking into consideration that I just lost 50 rating points or 10 rating points or whatever it was. Right. So it was always the baseline was the chess result. And then. Maybe it was a bit better than the results are a bit worse, but that's the baseline of how I felt. And that's very strong sign of identifying with the results.
And if you can you know, if you can feel yourself, Oh yeah, I have the same thing, it's very, very important that you start to learn that you as a person are different than you as a chess player. So you can play bad chess. You are not a bad person. You can make a stupid move, but you are not a stupid person.
That's extremely important. Might sound [00:17:00] obvious, but for many people, especially subconsciously there is no difference to that. Me playing good chess means I'm good person. Me playing bad chess means I'm a bad person. So I have three questions for you that you can realize if you Chess or the chess results are part of your identity.
So question number one, have you ever told yourself to be stupid after making a mistake? If yes, you identify in some part with your chess playing. Question number two, did you ever lose confidence in your abilities outside of the game of chess after losing a chess game? So let's say you just lost a chess game.
Somebody would ask you some kind of math problem and you would say, well, I just, you know, played such a bad game. I can't solve that problem. If you answer that with yes, you identify with your chess results. Question number three, has a certain rating title ever made you feel [00:18:00] better about yourself as a person?
Well, for example, if I think I'm worthy only if I have the grandmaster title, that's actually a big, big problem. And we see that in the chess world, for example. The biggest chess YouTuber, Gotham Chess, Levi Roseman. He's trying so hard to get a Grandmaster title because apparently he can't feel good about himself as an international master, which makes me feel sorry for him because I think he can feel good about himself as a person, just without being a GM, what does this leather change?
Nothing at all, in my opinion, but that's a process everybody Has to go through. And I would say that 90 percent of you still listening to this podcast are answering all of the three questions with yes, not only one, but all of the three. And it's very, very important to make the distinction that I made previously already between.
I made a mistake and [00:19:00] I made something stupid or I am stupid. Okay. The problem is when you do something stupid in chess and you take it over into your person, that's the huge. Okay. So these are all the problems that we have. And now I try to give you some solutions, how to make losses less painful and how to be able to play chess games without the anxiety of losing.
So I just want to be very clear, never in my career was I feeling you know, that I have it fully under control or that I don't care at all, or that no single part of my identity is connected to my chess results. I just want to say, I found some things that have been super helpful and that have made it less painful when I lost games.
And I worked with a sports psychologist. So, yeah. This is like a buffet of options that you can try [00:20:00] out or some ideas that you can try out. And hopefully something will stick for you and make it a little bit, you know, less painful losing games. And just the first thing I want to tell you is that you guys listening, I guess everyone or nearly everyone will be an amateur and chess will be a hobby for them.
So in parentheses, it's easier for you. Because you don't have to make a living so really your chess playing skills do not matter at all for your health for your family for your You know financial gains. So just remind yourself of that at all times. So here is what helped me the most. Point number one, accepting that perfection is impossible.
Point number two, building an identity of the chessboard. Point number three, finding perspective. Understanding that chess after all is [00:21:00] only a game. So let's get into perfection is impossible. Chess is a really, really hard game. And you will always make mistakes. If the best human on this earth, Magnus Carlsen, will look at his games, he will see that he makes mistakes in basically all his games.
So, we, as mere humans and not greatest of all times, we need to accept that for us this is even more true. We'll make mistakes every single game we play. So, instead of judging every single move, we And whenever I would see a, you know, engine evaluation, that wasn't what I was playing. I started judging my input, my energy, the how I tried my best.
So my question became instead of, did I make the right move is, did I give [00:22:00] my best trying to find the best move right here? And if the answer was yes. I could accept all the mistakes. Mistakes are learning opportunities, and I don't need to feel bad about myself. So instead of asking yourself, did I make the best move in this position?
Or did I play a perfect game? Start asking yourself, did I give my best during that game? And if the answer is yes, you can accept. mistakes as part of the process. So I really try to work on that with my sports psychologist of an understanding that I cannot do more than try to play my best chess, improve my mistakes, and try to play my best chess again.
So if you expect yourself to play Better than you actually can. This means pain. And I see that with many amateurs looking at their games and, you know, correcting even the [00:23:00] slightest mistakes in the opinion of the engine, and you're just setting yourself up for failure. So. Expect that things go wrong and expect, especially if you play quicker chess online, that you will make big mistakes.
That's, you know, that's because chess is hard, but you can still give your best and maybe even win the games. So don't feel bad about yourself just when the engine goes up. And the last thing here is really that I try to analyze my mistakes with less judgment. So, Oh my God, I'm so stupid. Why did I even play this move?
But more curiosity. It's like, Oh, what went wrong here? How, how come I didn't see that Bishop was hanging, you know? So with some curiosity, I can learn a lot and I can judge myself. Point number two, to make chess less painful, is to build an identity of the board. And for many years, playing chess professionally basically was my identity.[00:24:00]
As I mentioned, if Alessia would ask me, it was basically my second identity. biggest thing, my fiance, my girlfriend back then if she would ask me how I felt, I would always take into consideration basically only my chess result. And that makes it very tough because if I have only one, or let's say chess and her as a relationship, that two things that count, it's way easier to feel bad about myself if one of these two things are actually going badly.
But once I started having an identity that I said, okay, I care about, you know, care more about my family. I care more about my friends. I care more about the influence I have on people that follow me as a chess player. Then I started, you know, developing this kind of identity that is not as closely linked to my chess results.
And. Here I have some ideas [00:25:00] of how you can do that. And the most important thing is really to Stay away from being always the chess guy. So for a long time Whenever I got introduced somewhere I would be the chess grandmaster, right? So already it's linked or the chess genius or however, they wanted to call me So it was already linked my identity how new people met me was chess So what I tried is I just didn't introduce myself anymore about chess That I was a chess player.
I would say for example, I'm an entrepreneur and just be a little bit vague have say, okay I have a coaching business or something like that So I would try to meet people that like me as a person not because i'm a good chess player But just because well, I am noel and I have my opinions and my ideas and my actions And they are not dependent on how well I do in chess second step would be take your rating or title or whatever connected to your chest result out of your social media profiles.
[00:26:00] Take it out of anywhere where somebody could see it, right? That's the same kind of idea of like, you don't want that. The first thing somebody sees of you is your chest results, because then. You think that you are only worth something if you keep those up or if you improve them, just, you know, put them to the side.
You can say I'm a chess enthusiast, but it's not, I'm a chess, I'm a 1935 rated chess player, something like that, right? Take it, take the joy of chess, but not the result of chess that is in your personality. And then start talking more about it. about the process. So start talking about how you like the, you know, training of chess, how you like the beauty of chess, how you enjoy the fact of being in a flow state when you play chess and stop only taking the joy out of, I just want a game.
I feel good myself. So this is like [00:27:00] a distancing from your chess personality. And then obviously just Do some other stuff like I started taking days off, I started you know, meeting more people. I started going out with my friends again from time to time. So I just started having a life basically. So if your life is only turning around chess or whatever you talk about all the time is chess, chess, chess then that's a problem.
Now I think again, you're not professional players. I think it should be less extreme for you guys. But I'm just saying if your life is only chess results, chess results will be extremely painful when they are. And my sports psychologist gave like an amazing analogy here where he said that every part of your life can be like a, let's say building.
And the whole city that you're building is as stable. So it's more, let's say the highest building in the [00:28:00] city is more stable if they are like buildings next to it. Okay. So you are, if you're having only one skyscraper and you don't have any other buildings, it's very easy for that skyscraper to get destroyed.
Or when the skyscraper is doing badly. The whole city is kind of in shambles, but when you have like, you know, 30 houses as your personality was 30 different things that you value yourself in. It's like, I'm a good friend. I'm a good partner. I'm a good influence. Like all of these kinds of things, the more things that you know, take place in your personality, the easier it is to say, okay, five of these 30 things aren't going great, but I have 25 things that are going great.
I don't care. Okay. So by the way, he explained this analogy with the houses and stuff way better than me. So I'm sorry for that, but I hope you understood what I meant. Okay. So it shouldn't become any more that you're saying I am stupid because of chess. [00:29:00] I am a bad person because of chess, because again, it's just one of 15, 10, five things that are.
in your personality and not the one. And then the last thing is to find perspective. And to find perspective might be a little bit radical sometimes, but it can really help a lot. I remember having a lot of self pity for myself after losing two games in a row in a grandmaster tournament. I was thinking I'm so bad, but I'm also so poor and everything is bad.
Am I investing so much time in this? And why is it going so badly? And I was close to crying in my room. I was really angry. It was just all around horrible. But then I had this one little book on my computer. Nightstand in the hotel room, which was man's search for meaning from I think, how is he called?
Victor Frankel, Victor Frankel. So this is a person that went [00:30:00] through the Auschwitz concentration camp. Okay. So that's something that is so bad. And so, you know, different from what my pain is, or I lost the chess game. That I started to realize, Oh my God, if I take perspective, then I can realize that my life is actually amazing.
I'm in a beautiful hotel. I get food every day. I don't even have to cook. You know, they just bring me like these three meals. Perfect. Everything nice. I can. Do my hobby professionally and I'm crying. Well, this guy now comes to the best point. Viktor Frankl says that he has his feelings, that he's responsible for his feelings.
In the concentration camp in Auschwitz during the second world war like what the heck? So he manages to stay positive in the concentration camp and [00:31:00] i'm crying around because I lose some games of chess Well, that's a little bit difficult. So somehow this opened my eyes and I was like, okay Let's stop crying.
Let's just start playing chess and try to enjoy the moment. And sometimes it can really be a very good reminder. There are just people that are way, way, way worse off than we are. And if we have this privilege of playing a game and enjoying the game and trying to get better at the game, even if it sometimes doesn't work.
or life is pretty damn amazing, then we have the perspective to take losses less personal and to understand that, well, you know, there are way more important things in life and I'm happy I'm doing pretty well on those. If you wonder how the tournament went, Well, I scored five out of six in the remaining rounds, and I was just way [00:32:00] happier and enjoyed the moment.
And sadly, even in 2024, we don't have to look too far to see people that have, are way worse off than we are. Than I would say most of the people listening to this podcast. I don't want to say that you don't have your struggles Your life might be way harder than than mine. I accept that but you can always find somebody There's way worse off than you and say, okay I'm grateful to have my life to have chess in my life to have chess as a hobby And i'm trying to take it less personal and even if I lose a few games everything's Okay, okay guys, that was a long one.
I hope you take something out of it It's really very important to me that people that like chess can see chess as a hobby and that chess doesn't have to be painful or Difficult or all of these things it should be [00:33:00] nice. It should be fun. Yes, you will have hard moments But finding the perspective, taking it less personal is, if I can achieve that through my podcasts, through my newsletters, through my courses, then I have achieved in my profession, I believe.
So if somebody has a story they want to share with me, again, you can use the comment section. You can find my email. If you go to nextlevelchess. blog, that's my homepage, you can read articles there. Just try to stay a little bit more positive and see the chess results in the right perspective.